Students Occupy for Health Justice

By Danielle Alexander for AMSA On Call blog

I met a patient last week who stopped taking her antidepressant medications because she had been denied long-term health insurance and thought it would improve her chances of eligibility. Unfortunately this obviously wasn’t in the best interest of her health.

I had another patient who presented to the emergency department with metastatic lung cancer. He had not been to the doctor in over 30 years because he couldn’t afford it. If he had sought treatment earlier he may have been cured.

Everywhere I look private health insurance companies are making our patients sicker.

I was proud to be at in Lafayette Park in Albany, N.Y., last Sunday for the Health Professional Students Day of Action for the 99%. We carried a banner that said “Health Professional Students Occupy for Health Justice and Single Payer.”

I support the occupy movement because I feel that powerful and profiting insurance companies get in the way of my practice of medicine. Treatment should be the same high quality for everyone; instead, we have to consider what someone can afford.

It too often becomes treatment for the “haves” and neglect for the “have nots.” But the thing is, these days you may not know which group you fall into. Insurance plans are so spotty, with major gaps in coverage, that you don’t even realize it until you need medical attention, and you find your plan does not cover it.

I see it every day in the clinic – treatment is designed around what the insurance will pay (or not) instead of what is best for the patient first and foremost. It’s no fault of the medical team; we want to give the patients the best care, but the insurance industry has our hands tied.

Today’s future doctors realize that health care is more than physical health, social determinants of health are equally as important. The schools our kids attend, the neighborhoods we grow up in, the cleanliness of the environment, joblessness, and poverty all deeply impact our health.

A classmate said today, “There is so much inequity and injustice, it cuts into everything, including caring for patients. If you really want to care for patients you’ve got to care about everything, not just their liver.”

I asked some of the other attendees why they support the Occupy movement. “Health care is a fundamental human right and by increasing access to health care we can reduce some of the inequality,” said one medical student. Another classmate agreed: “We’re here for health care because you can’t do anything if you’re not healthy.” Yet another: “As a future physician, it’s disconcerting that patients can’t get into my exam room, and I want to change that.”

Even early in their medical careers, these students see that there are major problems with the health of our nation.

As I talked with my classmates, I found that we were all there for slightly different reasons. “I feel like too much of our country’s infrastructure has been diverted away from the important stuff like health and well-being,” said another student. His peer believes “the system is broken and change needs to start somewhere.”

The United States is the only industrialized country that does not provide health care to all its citizens regardless of employment status or economic class. Our profit-driven health care industry raises costs and inequality.

But our political system has been corrupted by corporate money and power, and the 1% have rejected evidence-based health policy that save lives and money, namely expanded and improved Medicare for all. We support Occupy Wall Street because economic and social inequality makes our patients sick.

Danielle Alexander is a medical student in Albany, N.Y.


  1. Debbie Wilson on December 22, 2011 at 6:55 pm

    Is This Part of the 99%?

    There was a precious little boy not quite three years old, when his mother was struck down by a pick up truck in a Kentucky Fried Chicken parking lot.
    His step-father hung in there and helped the young boy until he was eleven years old. The boy’s older sisters moved on and made wonderful lives for themselves. The eleven year old son chose to stay behind and help his brain injured, epileptic mother every step of the way.
    In December of 2011, when the boy was a man of 25 years and a father with sole custody of his own son, the Department of Rehab fired him after 6 years of employment. This left his mother with no home health care plan or supervision. He was fired based on his statement to his mother’s caseworker that he could not care for her for any fewer hours. After his termination this wonderful young man still stayed by his mother’s side. Thank God he did, or I, his mother would not be alive. I would have died last week when I had to be intubated due to a seizure that caused me to stop breathing. My son found me unconscious on the bathroom floor.
    This is a sad story anytime of the year but especially at Christmas time. The real sadness I feel as this young mans mother is that he has donated years of his care for free. He once again donated his care for free, since he had been fired as my personal assistant.
    Now, this grown man is fearful of leaving the house. He is having nightmares, and wakes up to come and see if I am still breathing. He has been totally traumatized by the Department of Rehabilitation’s push for budget cuts.
    I am all for budget cuts in the right places. However, when families are torn apart as a result of so called budget cuts someone needs to know. Now YOU do know what is going on in Jackson County, IL.
    If you have any questions or comments you can email me at