Renew Auto Industry? Start With Real Health Reform

By John Nichols for the Nation

General Motors, and what is left of Chrysler, are back asking for another government bailout. And Americans who recognize that an auto industry is a good deal more vital to the country’s future than those bankers who are using taxpayer billions to retrofit their executive washrooms will be inclined to sympathize with the plea.

But before another bailout check is inked, wouldn’t it make sense to get the auto giants – even if they are not so giant anymore – involved in addressing what really ails their industry?

No, it is not autoworkers. Members of the United Autoworkers union have given concession after concession after concession in order to save an industry that their union leadership called for modernizing – with the development of smaller, fuel-efficient cars – more than three decades ago.

And, no, it is not entirely the visionless management of GM, Chrysler and Ford, although it frustrating to recall the opportunities missed by CEOs who rejected smart union advocacy on behalf of the industry’s long-term future in favor of ever-bulkier SUVs, schemes to turn from manufacturing to financial services and, when it came time to balance the books, factory closures and layoffs.

The truth is that U.S. auto firms are being battered by a global economic collapse that has undermined car sales everywhere, leading to demands for government bailouts in every country where cars are made. But the even greater truth is that U.S. firms have been hit harder than many of their competitors by stalling car sales.

That’s because it costs more to make cars in the United States. Even though U.S. autoworkers have accepted pay cuts and efficiency schemes that mean they make less than autoworkers in many other countries, the enormous expense imposed by this country’s for-profit health care system places an extreme burden on firms that manufacture vehicles in the U.S. How extreme? It is estimated that health care costs add as much as $1,400 to the cost of a car made in an American plant.

Continue reading.


  1. Eliza Jane Dodd on February 24, 2009 at 12:11 pm

    This moring TV News and FOX at that let president Obamas remarks about WE are getting a UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE !!!! So watch tonight ! I have never been so excited like this …I have so much to say …Number One is I am going to LIVE !! Now I am going to call and email the White House and thank them ! And I Thank You also Health Care Now . org ! GOD BLESS You and Sweet Katie ! This is a BLESSED DAY IN AMERICA ! Kisses and Hugs to all mankind ! My tears are falling and they are Tears of JOY !